← Back to blog

Underpayment Penalty Waiver: What Qualifies and How to Ask

November 16, 2026
Underpayment Penalty Waiver: What Qualifies and How to Ask

The IRS can waive the estimated tax underpayment penalty, but only in narrow cases: a casualty, disaster or other unusual circumstance, or a retirement after age 62 or a disability. Ordinary reasons, such as a cash-flow squeeze, a late-year spike in income or a missed due date, are not grounds on their own. For most high earners, the better route is to lower the penalty with the methods built into Form 2210. Those are the annualized income method and treating withholding as paid on the dates it was actually withheld. Here is how to tell which route fits you and how to ask correctly.

Thetaxrefinery
Plan Ahead for Tax Payment Shortfalls
The Tax Refinery provides year-round tax advisory for business owners seeking strategic planning beyond annual return preparation.
Visit

TL;DR

  • A waiver is available for a casualty, disaster or unusual circumstance, or for a retirement after age 62 or disability, when the underpayment had reasonable cause. Reasonable cause alone does not qualify.
  • You request it on Form 2210, Part II: box A for the whole penalty, box B for part of it, with a signed statement and documents attached.
  • Business owners and high earners usually get further with reduction methods: the annualized income installment method (Schedule AI) or the withholding timing election.
  • The penalty is figured separately for each quarterly due date, so paying enough later does not erase an earlier shortfall.
  • Fixing the safe harbor math before the next quarter is cheaper than any waiver request.

Table of Contents

What the underpayment penalty is

The IRS charges the penalty to individuals, estates and trusts that do not pay enough estimated tax or pay it late. Estimated payments are generally due April 15, June 15, September 15 and January 15 of the following year. If a date lands on a weekend or legal holiday, the payment is on time if made the next business day.

The amount depends on three things: how much you underpaid, how long it stayed unpaid, and the quarterly interest rate the IRS publishes for underpayments. The rate changes each quarter, so look up the current one on the IRS penalty page rather than relying on an old figure. The calculation starts from the tax shown on your original return, which is total tax minus refundable credits.

This matters to business owners, S corporation shareholders, partners and sole proprietors because nobody withholds on their business income. Publication 6147-B says individuals who expect to owe at least $1,000 after withholding should make estimated payments. It also lists sole proprietors, partners and S corporation shareholders among them.

What the underpayment penalty is

When you owe it, and when you don't

For 2025 returns, the Form 2210 instructions say you generally owe the penalty if your withholding plus timely estimated payments fell short of the smaller of two amounts:

  • 90% of your 2025 tax, or
  • 100% of your 2024 tax, provided the 2024 return covered 12 months.

If your 2024 adjusted gross income (AGI) was over $150,000 ($75,000 if married filing separately for 2025), the second figure becomes 110% of your 2024 tax. That 110% rule is the one most readers in our audience fall under.

There is no penalty, and no form is needed, if you had no 2024 tax liability for a full 12-month year, or if your 2025 tax minus withholding is under $1,000. Check these before assuming you owe anything.

A worked example

Say a nurse practitioner earns W-2 wages and also runs a consulting S corporation. This is a hypothetical, not a real client.

  • 2024 total tax: $90,000. 2024 AGI was above $150,000, so the prior-year test is 110%: $99,000.
  • 2025 total tax turns out to be $120,000. 90% of that is $108,000.
  • The smaller figure is $99,000, so that is the target. Spread evenly, it is $24,750 per quarter.

If withholding plus estimates reach $99,000 on time, the penalty is zero, even though the actual 2025 bill is $21,000 higher. Our guide to safe harbor estimated taxes walks through this math for self-employed filers.

Which circumstances qualify for a waiver

The IRS states that the estimated tax penalty generally cannot be waived due to reasonable cause. The Internal Revenue Manual repeats the point: reasonable cause alone is not enough, and waiver criteria are limited to those in the form instructions and the tax code. This is where the estimated tax penalty differs from late-filing or late-payment penalties. Those can be abated for reasonable cause, as our reasonable cause letter guide explains.

The 2025 Form 2210 instructions say the IRS may waive all or part of the penalty in two situations:

  1. Retirement or disability. You retired after reaching age 62, or became disabled, in 2024 or 2025, and the underpayment was due to reasonable cause, not willful neglect.
  2. Casualty, disaster or unusual circumstance. The underpayment was due to one of these, and it would be inequitable to impose the penalty.

For federally declared disaster areas, the relief is largely automatic. The Internal Revenue Manual says the IRS may disregard a period of up to one year in deciding whether payments were timely. It adds that its systems generally adjust penalties for widespread disasters without a manual request. If your address is in a covered area, check your notice before filing a request.

What usually does not qualify

The following are common, understandable reasons, but they are not listed grounds for a waiver:

  • A large client payment, bonus or capital gain arrived late in the year.
  • Your accountant or payroll provider missed a quarter.
  • Cash was tied up in the business, in a new practice or in a property purchase.
  • You didn't know estimated payments applied to S corporation or partnership income.

The next section shows what to do in those cases.

How to request the waiver on Form 2210

The 2025 Form 2210 instructions set out the process:

  1. Complete Form 2210, Part II. Check box A to request a waiver of the entire penalty. You file page 1 only and don't have to figure the penalty. Check box B to request a partial waiver.
  2. For a partial waiver, figure the full penalty first. Work through line 18, enter the waived amount in parentheses next to line 19, and subtract it.
  3. Attach a statement. Explain why you couldn't meet the estimated tax requirements and give the time period the explanation covers.
  4. Attach proof. For retirement or disability, that means documentation of the retirement date and your age on it, or the disability date. For a casualty, disaster or unusual circumstance, attach copies of police and insurance reports.
  5. File it with your return. The IRS reviews the request and decides whether to grant it.

If the penalty has already been assessed on a notice, the IRS penalty page says to send a written explanation, signed under penalty of perjury, to the address on the notice.

Keep the statement factual and dated. Name the event, the dates, which quarterly payments it affected and how it caused the shortfall. A clean timeline with documents attached reads better than a long narrative.

A caution on the tax year: the 2025 instructions govern returns for 2025. The IRS has also posted a draft 2026 Form 2210, so confirm which version applies to your return before filing.

What to do when you don't qualify: reduce the penalty

The IRS penalty page lists options beyond waivers. For business owners and high earners, these are where the money is.

Annualized income installment method

If your income was uneven, such as a seasonal business, a large late-year gain or an S corporation distribution at year-end, the required installments can shrink. The Schedule AI instructions say the annualized method can lower or eliminate the required installments. If you use it for any due date, you must use it for all of them. You check box C in Part II, complete Schedule AI using your accounting method for each period, and attach Parts I, II and III and Schedule AI to your return.

Steps for using the annualized income method

The catch is bookkeeping. Schedule AI needs income and deductions figured period by period, so clean, current books decide whether it is practical. That is the main reason owners with several entities struggle to use it without a running picture of each entity's profit.

Withholding timing

Withholding is normally treated as paid evenly across the year. If most of your tax was withheld early, the penalty can be lower when withholding is treated as paid on the dates it was actually withheld, which is box D in Part II of the draft 2026 form. For a W-2 earner with side income, the same logic points to a planning move. Raising W-2 withholding late in the year can cover shortfalls from earlier quarters, because withholding is the one source of payment that can be timed. Estimated payments cannot be backdated.

Other reductions

The IRS penalty page also lists a retirement after age 62 or disability within the past two years, for you or a spouse on a joint return, with reasonable cause. The draft 2026 form adds a box E for joint returns filed for 2025 or 2026 but not both, where line 8 is smaller than line 5.

Quarters are scored separately

The Form 2210 instructions point out that the penalty is figured for each installment due date. You can owe it for an earlier quarter even if you later paid enough to make up the difference, and even if you are due a refund. So a big April true-up does not undo a missed June payment. Only a waiver or a reduction method does.

Quick decision guide

Your situationBest first moveForm 2210
Hurricane, wildfire or other declared disaster hit your areaCheck whether relief was applied automatically; if not, request a waiverBox A or B
Casualty or theft affected your ability to payRequest a waiver with police and insurance reportsBox A or B
Retired after 62 or became disabled in 2024 or 2025Request a waiver with dated documentationBox A or B
Income came late in the yearAnnualized income methodBox C and Schedule AI
Most tax was withheld in Q4Treat withholding as paid when withheldBox D
Simply underpaid with no qualifying eventReduce with the methods above; fix safe harbor going forwardBox C or D as it applies

If the penalty stays on your account

A waiver request that is denied, or a penalty you skip paying, becomes part of your balance, and balances that go unaddressed move toward notices and collection. Our guide to the CP504 notice explains the 30-day window before levy risk. If a lien ever attaches to property you plan to sell, the process for selling a home with an IRS lien involves Form 14135 and escrow. Neither is where you want to end up over a penalty that proper quarterly planning would have avoided.

Penalties unrelated to estimated payments follow different rules. If you also face a late-filing or late-payment penalty, the first-time penalty abatement guide covers that relief, and our article on medical professionals' quarterly taxes covers the payment schedule.

Perspective

Most people who ask us about a waiver are looking at a penalty that has already happened. The waiver rules are narrow, so for owners netting $300,000 to $1,000,000 the real fix is upstream.

A multi-entity owner has income landing in an S corporation, a partnership and sometimes a W-2 job. Without a running view of what each one will produce, quarterly payments become guesses. We build planning around that view: setting the safe harbor target in January, checking it each quarter, and adjusting withholding or estimates before a due date passes.

Our approach is year-round tax strategy, not a once-a-year filing. When a penalty does land, we can also help with the Form 2210 and with IRS representation. The cheapest penalty is the one that never gets assessed.

Melissa

How we can help

If you are tired of estimating quarterly payments, our Quarterly Tax Strategy Sessions are $9,497 per year, and our Monthly Tax Advisory is $11,997 per year. S corporation owners can start with the S-Corp Tax Strategy Accelerator at $997 one-off. Tax preparation is priced by form on our fee schedule, for example $1,800 for a Form 1120-S. If a penalty or notice is already in front of you, see our tax resolution service.

Thetaxrefinery

FAQ

Can I get the underpayment penalty waived because I had a good reason?

Good reason alone is not enough. The IRS says the estimated tax penalty generally cannot be waived for reasonable cause by itself. It can be waived for a casualty, disaster or unusual circumstance, or for a retirement after 62 or a disability when the underpayment had reasonable cause.

Do I need to file Form 2210 to avoid the penalty?

Not always. If you owe less than $1,000 after withholding, or had no 2024 tax for a full 12-month year, no penalty or form applies for 2025. Otherwise, you may attach Form 2210 to request a waiver or to use a reduction method. The IRS will also figure the penalty and bill you if you don't file it.

What is the difference between box A and box B for a waiver?

Box A requests a waiver of the entire penalty, and you file page 1 only. Box B requests a waiver of part of it, so you figure the full penalty, enter the waived amount and subtract it on line 19.

Does paying the shortfall later remove the penalty?

No. The penalty is figured separately for each installment due date, so a late catch-up payment stops the penalty from growing but does not erase what built up. A waiver or one of the reduction methods is what changes the amount.

Sources